Bury Council admits its report on selling Milton Road fields in Radcliffe for the Ash Grove school counted 20 objections, not 48. Scrutiny has sent the sale back to Cabinet.
Bury Council has admitted that 28 objections to selling Milton Road fields in Radcliffe were left out of the report Cabinet used to approve the sale. Cabinet was told there were 20 objections. There were 48.
Updated 5 November: on 3 November Overview and Scrutiny referred the decision back to Cabinet with five recommendations, and it made no comment on the academy decision. Cabinet took the item on 4 November; the result is not yet published. Our Cabinet report has the full breakdown of the objections.
The admission is in a report for councillors on the Overview and Scrutiny Committee. They meet on Tuesday 3 November at 7.30pm to look at the decision after Radcliffe First councillors Judi Sheppard and Carol Birchmore called it in.
The land is earmarked for the new Ash Grove Alternative Provision Academy. Cabinet approved both the sale and the school on 14 October, as we reported at the time.
What went missing
The council has to advertise any sale of public open space and consider objections. It placed notices in the Bury Times on 27 August and 3 September, with a closing date of 24 September.
Residents’ letters were handed in at the Town Hall. The council’s investigation found:
- The envelope reached Property Services and was date-stamped on 9 September.
- On 17 September an officer scanned one item, an open letter signed by 20 residents of Moorfield Sheltered Housing on Wordsworth Avenue, into the property inbox.
- Eight more letters, each signed by a different resident, were not scanned. They were “mistakenly believed to be duplicates” and stayed in the envelope at the Town Hall.
- The officer watching the inbox did not spot the scanned letter as an objection, so it never reached the folder used to collect them.
The report concludes that Cabinet “should have referenced a total of 48 objections, not 20”. It says several experienced property staff retired in the last year, which “may have left a knowledge gap”.
What the missed letters said
The council’s summary of the Moorfield letter lists:
- a well-used, accessible community space
- its value for residents’ health and wellbeing
- more traffic, noise and disturbance
- community safety and safeguarding
- pressure on stretched local services
The eight other letters raised the loss of green space, harm to health and wellbeing, community safety, and a “failure to explore alternative locations”.
What the council proposes now
Officers recommend a further report to Cabinet “in due course” setting out all 48 objections. Two identified officers will now open any posted objections on future open space sales and check they are filed.
The report also restates the council’s case for the site. Its March 2026 Open Space Assessment scored the 1.47 hectare field at 46.2% for quality, below a 50% threshold, and 18.0% for value, below 20%. It describes the land as “an overgrown grassed area with no signage or seating”.
Radcliffe has 0.81 hectares of amenity green space per 1,000 people, against a recommended 0.64. Losing all of Milton Road would cut that to 0.76, the report says. A community garden at the east end of the site would be kept and improved.
A second call-in, on the school itself
Councillors have also called in Cabinet’s decision on the academy. Their request draws on the planning consultants’ report on the public consultation held on 29 September. It recorded 62 people attending and 32 written responses:
| Concern | Responses | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Loss of green space and wellbeing | 21 | 66% |
| Crime, anti-social behaviour and drugs | 17 | 53% |
| Traffic, parking and road safety | 17 | 53% |
| Suitability of the location | 10 | 31% |
Residents suggested other sites, including Derby High School on Bury Road, Cams Lane, Redvales, land next to Newbank Garden Centre, and expanding an existing school. The councillors want to know how those were assessed.
The first call-in also asks for the full feasibility study, which looked at six sites.
What happens next
The agenda sets out three options. The committee can make no comment, and Cabinet’s decision stands. It can send comments or objections back to Cabinet. Or it can refer the matter to full Council. Cabinet must consider any objections but is not bound by them.
The meeting has a 30-minute public question time. The agenda and papers are on the council’s meeting page.
What it means for you
If you objected to the sale and are not sure your letter was counted, the council now says 48 objections will go back to Cabinet. You can also ask a question at the scrutiny meeting on 3 November.
The school would need planning permission as well. That application would bring its own chance to comment, and it will appear on our Bury planning news page. Background on the school is in our earlier report on the Ash Grove plans.
Have your say